
With two years worth of hype, a mostly strong cast, and nearly perfect premiere, Survivor 50 had everything going for it. But after a whole season of forced celebrity inclusions and twists galore capped off by an underwhelming ending, many people leave the Survivor 50 experience disappointed. That’s not to say Survivor 50 was a bad season of Survivor. It was still great to see all of these players come back and there were a lot of great story arcs throughout the season. It’s impossible to ignore the twists and celebrities, though. So, that brings up many questions. Are the twists and celebrities to blame for the faults of 50? Not only in terms of the time they take up in episodes, but also in how they affected the outcome of the game. Did we reach this underwhelming result because of twists, or was it always meant to be this way? And finally, would Survivor 50 have been in the running for G.O.A.T. if the players were actually allowed to play the game?
1. An Epic Party: Incredible Start
Oh how hopeful everyone was… ‘An Epic Party’ was a really strong start to the season. Everything about it felt like a celebration of Survivor. Of course, there’s the beautiful montage at the start of the episode. But there’s also so many callbacks to iconic moments of Survivor, with the most glaring example being the return of Coach vs. Ozzy. The interactions between players from different eras of Survivor was great. Rick and Christian as a duo makes so much sense. Both of the 49 players having nice moment with Colby was great. And even though it was devastating to see Jenna be the first boot, the show did an amazing job paying tribute to her. Jeff’s chat with her at tribal council and the old tribal council music after her vote off were great ways to show some love to Jenna. Kyle’s unfortunate med evac ends the episode on a sadder note, but doesn’t take away from how great everything leading up to it was. The twists here are not overwhelming, with both the journey and return of Exile Island leading to great moments.
But then, there’s the Billie Eilish Boomerang Idol. The first brand new twist and instance of celebrity inclusions, the BEBI is… bad. First of all, it wasn’t even Billie Eilish’s idea! The producers simply sent her ideas and had her pick one. Moving past that, it was an interesting idea that I was willing to give a shot. But in execution, it’s awful and stifling to gameplay. The biggest example of this is the first person to find the BEBI, Genevieve. Nothing about the BEBI works! Because Genevieve gives away both of her BEBIs, she has nothing to protect herself when she’s twist screwed during the Blood Moon. She would’ve had two idols any other season! The BEBI also encourages people to talk about idols, with Genevieve telling every one of her allies about the BEBI, which spreads to everyone by the merge. That led to every 50 idol being a public one. The boomerang aspect of it also didn’t work and likely won’t on most seasons. Genevieve predicted Ozzy’s downfall, but she was voted out long before she could receive the idol. There’s also the fact that the BEBI can only be played for yourself. That not only severely limits what people can do with them, but because BEBIs replaced traditional idols, means nobody besides Devens could do anything interesting with their idols this season. BEBIs were a flop that stifled gameplay that never should have replaced idols or even the beware advantage.
6. Therapy Carousel: Fun vs Joe
‘Therapy Carousel’ was a solid follow up to the premiere, but it is also the episode where one of the season’s chronic problems emerges. That problem is the underediting of many different players, mostly women, throughout the season. Five players get zero confessionals in this episode and all five of them were women. It is an issue that persists and leads to one of the most underedited winners in Survivor history and a purple fifth placer.
That’s the only problem that there is with this episode though, as I feel like it’s interesting in every other regard. There are plenty of great character moments, which can often get overshadowed by strategy in the New Era. There’s Christian’s crappy khakis, Coach’s ocean cramp, and the feud between Devens and Joe. Plus, you can’t forget Christian rocking Joe in the hammock! While most of the moments mentioned are just pure fun, Devens vs Joe presents a lot more intrigue. Devens represents the fun of the game, taking full advantage of every idol and twist. Joe represents stubbornness and being stuck in your ways. Joe overall is given a much more negative edit on 50 than he was on 48, while Devens is given one of the most positive ones. It feels like we are meant to agree with Devens in this feud, even if he isn’t necessarily 100% in the right. As for the Savannah boot, it was a straightforward and predictable vote, but the journey there was fun. Savannah clocking Cirie and Ozzy’s dynamic before her exit really showcased how much potential there is for her. I really hope she’s on another season, one where she’s not dead on arrival.
3. Did You Vote For A Swap?: Emily’s Reign of Chaos
Swaps: a Survivor staple. You love it when it happens, but when one of your favorites is voted out because of a swap, you groan. Survivor 50’s swap is no different, with Q being the unfortunate victim. Despite that, this swap was a beautiful mess. The swapped tribe dynamics were for the most part amazing. The new Kalo was just fine, with the honor and integrity trio of Joe, Colby, and Coach coming together while the Aubry and Genevieve rivalry continues. New Cila and were so good though! On Cila, Rizo continues living out his superfan dream, landing him in trouble with Charlie. Their rivalry begins here, and it was without a doubt one of the best and most interesting dynamics of the season.
The real star of the show is Emily Flippen, though. It starts hours before the swap, when Christian and Devens fail to tell Emily about the BEBI. Then, Christian hastily tells her seconds before the swap, and she loses trust in him. What follows is a crazy sequence where Emily at first aligns with Q and Stephenie, telling them about the BEBI. She then quickly decides she doesn’t like them that much and tells Angelina that the two were targeting her. After doing all of that, she realizes she made a mistake telling everyone about the BEBI and apologizes to Christian, who seems genuinely mad. That’s not even mentioning the fact that the three David vs Goliath players are on the same tribe, that Emily suddenly sees Ozzy as one of her closest allies, or that Q has a plan to take votes away from Stephenie that backfires. It was all so electric and fun to watch, even if we ironically lose one of the most electric players as a result.
12. Knife To The Heart: Celebrity Fatigue
This episode is just frustrating. You have a great blindside in the Mike White vote. There are complex feelings all around, with the David vs Goliath trio coming apart at this vote, Emily getting Gabby comparisons, Christian’s feelings about Gabby’s betrayal on DvG. All of that is completely overshadowed because the editors decided they needed to give Zach Brown fifteen whole minutes to advertise his music! I’m not going to delve deep into that whole debacle again, I’ve already written everything that I needed to. It’s just a shame that so much great content will be forgotten because of the rightful frustration surrounding Zach Brown.
Zach Brown’s reign of terror put a dark tinge around the rest of the season. The Mr. Beast episode was still over the horizon. A lot of people expected him to have just as much, if not more, screentime in that episode. After three great episodes, this episode began the flood of negativity on social media that would persists throughout the rest of the season. Even despite most of the episodes past this one being good, the negativity never really left. ‘Knife To The Heart’ is where the unity 50 brought to the Survivor community went to die.
8. Open Wounds: The Theme Becomes Clear
Episode 5, in retrospect, does a great job at setting the theme for the rest of the season. The theme is how past Survivor traumas and experiences haunt you. After having so much time to think about their past mistakes, the Survivor 50 players all handle their emotions and actions differently, but with the shared goal to not fall into the same trap. Most inevitably do, but one will be able to reverse the curse. Charlie is the first true victim of failing to reverse his curse. Charlie’s whole arc on 50 revolves around his rivalry with Rizo, which the show portrays as being about Charlie perceiving Rizo as not having voted for his closest ally to win. Maria’s betrayal caused him to fall into the same trap. He is only the first of many to fall victim to their past.
I also want to take some time to discuss how important the Charlie boot is to the rest of the season. This vote causes original Kalo to completely fall apart. Dee and Kamilla both voting out Charlie severed any potential connection to Johnathan. In addition, Charlie and Mike were in the middle of original Kalo, which was split between Tiffany, Kamilla, and Dee versus Coach, Chrissy, and Johnathan. With both of them gone, those two sides are cut off from each other. The result? Kamilla, Dee, Chrissy, and Coach all gone basically back to back to back to back. I’ve spent so much time thinking about what would happen if Dee and Kamilla didn’t flip on Charlie or if they still flipped but voted out Johnathan instead. The season could be completely different, for the worse or better. All of this to say, twists are largely to blame for the underwhelming endgame of 50, but ultimately, many key decisions like the Charlie blindside led to a domino effect. There are so many points where you just wish something could have changed, but pondering on them now is pointless.
As for Angelina, her vote off was unfortunately foretold. She was a perennial target for most of the season and went out unceremoniously. It’s a shame her run went so poorly and that she was treated as an afterthought in her boot episode, but it was still nice to finally see her play again. Little did we know, this episode was the calm before the storm…
11. The Blood Moon: A Second Swap
Let’s face it, this was not a merge. At best, it was a glorified tribe swap. I get that there’s 24 players on 50 and that you need to narrow the field as quickly as possible, but this was such a bad way to go about it. Having three tribes of five each vote someone out led to three predictable votes where three people were screwed over. It would have been much better if they did three tribal councils in one night, having quick immunity challenges at tribal council in between each vote. That way, we could actually see the merged tribe dynamics play out! Speaking of which, the short segment where all seventeen players are on the same beach was awesome. We see Cirie’s Rizard of Oz form here, easily the best alliance of the season. In addition, the idol talk is electric and the potential Cirie and Genevieve alliance is one of my biggest what ifs of the season.
As for the three victims of the Blood Moon: Kamilla was my favorite player on 48 and seeing her play on 50 was amazing. Even if she was overshadowed by the other two boots, she was also twist screwed, considering her and Tiffany were pitted against a pregame alliance. Genevieve is quite clearly the most screwed over player this season, the biggest victim of the horrible amalgamation of twists on 50. And then there’s Colby, who was a shining ray of light this season. It was such a joy to see Colby for the six episodes he was a part of and his Survivor journey, even if cut way too short, was capped off beautifully. I kept on looking back to his ‘Find the Joy’ message every time I was frustrated during the rest of the merge.
9. That’s Not How I Play Survivor: The First True Merge Vote
The first true merge episode is quite similar to episode two. It has a lot of great character moments, especially everything surrounding Coach, but a predictable vote off. This is the only episode where the Honor and Integrity alliance has any true power. It is clear to see by the end of the episode why they are only able to keep power for one episode. None of them are good at Survivor. Coach, after having everyone coming into the season wanting to work with him, ends the episode with a scathing vote from Tiffany for him and embarrassingly having to be told to calm down by Rizgod of all people. Jonathan purposefully starts an argument with Dee to piss her off and seems to think it’s some kind of masterful move. Stephenie earns a vote steal from the journey and tries lying about it only for Cirie to quickly suspect her of lying and force her to admit the truth. Aubry, not a part of Honor and Integrity, humorously lies to everyone that she forgot to play her idol, which no one believes and she admits was a mistake. It is a horrific display of gameplay all around.
The tribal council was one of the more interesting ones on 50, with Dee giving a good last ditch effort to put more votes on Coach. Aubry burns her own idol, but gives a fire line as she plays it. And of course, there’s Tiffany’s voting confessional, which is one of the best of all time. As for Dee herself, she was a great mayor of Ponderosa and a fun player for the time she was there. Overall, a solid episode that is ultimately kind of overshadowed.
5. Double The Fun, Double The Demise: Best Twist Name Ever?
‘Double Duos’ is such a ridiculous name for a twist, I still find it hard to believe that’s what they ended up going with. Despite the dumb name, ‘Double Duos’ as a twist is one of the better ones in a season so bloated with them. That’s because the players actually had agency in who they were paired up with and it wasn’t determined by a rock draw. It is an interesting twist and one that I would not be opposed to seeing on another season.
As for how it worked on 50, it led to the satisfying downfall of Honor and Integrity. After Tiffany wins immunity alongside Joe at the perfect time, the duos of Aubry & Devens and Chrissy & Coach become the main targets. We get a great final episode from Chrissy & Coach, with Chrissy sending Coach to time out on the hammock because of how much of a liability he is. She ironically ends up putting a bigger target on their backs by targeting Rizo, though. And then we get the payoff to Christian and Devens’ hidden fake idol at tribal council when Devens pulls it out to save himself.
Of course, the biggest star of the episode is Cirie. She gets sent to Exile Island after not being in a pair, where she finds out she can only return to camp if she finds a Phoenix coconut. Once she finds the Phoenix and returns to camp, everyone is thankful for her presence and she effortlessly shifts the target to Chrissy & Coach. In a moment of tragic foreshadowing, Ozzy says he would have made a dumb move in voting out Aubry & Devens without Cirie’s presence. Unfortunately, this episode begins the streak of endless twists that eventually leads to the disappointing endgame.
10. I Deserve All Of This: The Worst of Both Worlds
The nerd alliance’s downfall was always going to happen. One way or another, it was inevitable. But the way it went down was just saddening to watch. Christian has a series of errors and mistakes throughout the entire episode, starting with him telling Cirie about his plan to target her closest ally and ending with Jonathan rubbing salt in his wound by giving back his shot in the dark as he’s grabbing his torch. And in the middle is the Jimmy Fallon of it all. The first part of Jimmy Fallon’s reign of terror was actually fun. He had Jeff compete in the immunity challenge, which led to a brief return of sassy Jeff. The second part, though? Not fun. Christian goes on a journey where he tragically loses and must complete Jimmy Fallon’s punishment. He takes a letter to read out loud at camp, which reveals he must vote for himself at tribal council. With that, Christian’s fate is sealed. In the midst of this, Christian doesn’t give up and says he must set a strong example for his son about not letting his worst moments bring him down. It’s inspiring, but doesn’t take away from how horrible the twist was. He had no chance to save himself after that, as much as he tried. It was so bad that Jimmy Fallon invited him on The Tonight Show as an apology. It was the worst of both worlds. An unnecessary celebrity appearance and a horrible twist combined in one.
2. A Side Dish of Chaos: Classic Fun
The auction’s back, this time, without any of the unnecessary additions from the New Era. It’s back to the classic auction rules. As a result, it’s certainly not the best auction of all time, but it is a solid one with fun, simple character moments. Aubry happily scarfing down both of the grubs for her and Rizo and getting sentimental about mac & cheese made her the star of the auction. This episode also has the first of many times in which Aubry mentions her loss to Michele in Koah Rong, setting up her winning arc of being the only person on 50 to actually reverse their curse.
Post-auction, episode 10 continues the theme of classic fun. There’s an amazing, chaotic pre-tribal scramble where the Honor and Integrity alliance makes their last hurrah, Jonathan leading the charge on targeting Ozzy only for it to end with him unintentionally getting Stephenie voted out. She seemed more than happy to take the fall for him though, so not much lost there. Rick Devens blows up Honor and Integrity at tribal council with all of the information he’s been given throughout the day and then successfully flips the Mr. Beast coin to earn immunity, an idol, and increase the prize pool to $2 million. Mr. Beast put the most thought and care into his celebrity appearance compared to the others and didn’t take time talking about himself, easily being the best celebrity appearance for those reasons. Unfortunately, the downside of the coin flip being automatically going home if you guess wrong drags his twist down. That is what prevents this episode from being the best of the season.
4. Everyone Will Be Shooketh: Overindulgence
We’re at the final nine, and we haven’t had a normal merge vote since the final fourteen. Every other merge vote, including the Blood Moon, has been compromised in some way. What do we do? A split tribal of course! Not just any split tribal, but one where the immunity winner will get more than just immunity. They will become the ‘Power Broker,’ having a vote in both tribal councils and as a result lots of power at camp. To give production credit, this twist is pretty interesting. It puts a new spin on the split tribal, which has become common place in the New Era. And here, it leads to two interesting rounds of gameplay in the Emily and Ozzy boots. This is a good episode, but the downside is we miss out on the crucial final 9 and final 8 votes, which have been key rounds of gameplay in the past. Ozzy’s downfall is as tragic as it is poetic. He goes home with an idol in his pocket again, succumbing to his curse. His downfall brings down Cirie as well, and if she were there to warn him, a totally different outcome would have happened. The episode was great, but its aftermath… not so much.
13. Inconceivable: Hungover After the Party
Endless twists have led to fun results. Double Duos, Jimmy Fallon, Mr. Beast, and the Power Broker all in succession have led to some headaches, but a lot of fun as well. We’ve had a great time at this party. Now, with only seven players left in the game, we’re left with a huge mess and lots of regret. Episode twelve is pretty easily the worst episode of the season, as we are forced to watch the slow death of both Devens and Cirie’s games. Idoless and Ozzyless, both of them are sitting ducks and easy targets during their boot rounds despite their best attempts to survive. Nothing they try saves them and an underwhelming final five remains. We’re all left wondering. We had a lot of fun, but was it worth it?
7. Reverse The Curse: Succumb to Your Fate
The theme of 50: Reversing your curse. It comes to a head here and leads to tragic endings for all of the finalists except for Aubry. Even if the final five was underwhelming, the way their journeys end was as tragic as it was entertaining to watch. Tiffany’s boot is predictable, unfortunately the weakest part of the finale. Rizo and Joe both succumbing to their curse while Jonathan falls to Aubry’s curse was fascinating to watch, though. Rizo becomes the first ever two-time firemaking loser while Joe is brought to the end as a goat once again. Jonathan now loses as the strategic player to a more social one, the exact curse that Aubry was once haunted by. Aubry is the only finalist to get a happy ending, healed from her past and a multi-millionaire. Plus, Jeff’s all-time blunder with Rizo and the juicy, bitter exit press from Jonathan made this finale a surprisingly good one.
Conclusion: Twist-Screwed?
Ultimately, you could spend hours going over the what ifs. What if this person was not voted out? What if this twist didn’t happen? What if that twist didn’t happen? You could think about it for days on end, imagining what if that one thing didn’t happen. That’s not productive at all, though, and you’ll only find yourself growing more and more frustrated. At the end of the day, there are many things to be mad about. Why did Jeff call this season “In The Hands of The Fans” if he’s just going to berate fans who complain about the bombardment of twists? But, as Colby said, the best thing to do is to find the joy. Sure, many things could have been handled better this season. There were questionable casting and production choices. But there was also something for almost every fan on 50. Everyone had at least one person to root for. Everyone had at least one moment they could resonate with. It’s better to find the things you like and focus on those rather than endlessly ponder on what if Genevieve and Survivor 50 weren’t twist screwed.
Rating: 7/10








